Hot Topics in On The Issue Magazine
OTI is furthering the discussion of Topics Hot in the News!
Share |

View and Leave a commentView Comments

Back to Hot Topics Home



How My Friend From Kabul Escaped an Honor Killing and Saved Her Life – So Far

by Mahnaz Rezaie

I am from Afghanistan. I am now an undergraduate student on scholarship at an American college. I was on campus last Sunday when I read – and agonized over – an article on the front page of The New York Times about the attempted “honor killing” of an Afghan teenager.

This young woman was from the provinces and dared to run away with a man who was not her husband. Along with emphasizing the horror of all this, I want Americans to know that this is not merely a practice of the provinces of my country. Kabul, the capital of Afghanistan, is in some ways a relatively sophisticated city. But this kind of wicked ignorance happens there too.

I also want Americans to know that some women manage to save their own lives. They hide and escape. A friend of mind from Kabul did just that. With a secret mobile phone she messaged her boyfriend from the bathroom of the family house where her father was keeping her a prisoner – and they plotted their escape.

That Sunday newspaper article told the story of Gul Meena, struck by an ax fifteen times because she “dishonored” her family.

My friend – before she ran away – was persecuted in the name of religion. But an honor killing can happen simply because a woman and a man fall in love without the permission of elders. That seems to have been the case with Gul Meena. It is said that Gul Meena broke fundamental moral codes.  I say that she broke absurd patriarchal laws.

On The Issues Magazine - Rezaie2  height=© Mahnaz Rezaie  I will call the friend who came to mind on Sunday “Samana.” I will call the boy with whom she fell in love and with whom she ran away “Khalid.” It would be too dangerous for me to use their real names.

Samana was an engineering student at Kabul University. Khalid sent his family and elders to Samana’s father to ask for her hand. He rejected the offer and imprisoned Samana in the house. He did this, he said, because Khalid was from another Islamic sect – Sunni – and Samana’s family is Shia. The boy begged Samana’s father to reconsider. But the father clung to his religious and cultural beliefs – and also beat his daughter for daring to defy them.

Samana, imprisoned in her house, was ridiculed and tortured by her two brothers, father and mother. The younger of those brothers had once been protective – and her best companion. Now he told her, “I will kill the boy you fell in love with, if I see him around here."

Samana’s mother had once been her best friend. Now she insulted her, cursed her and cried that she had brought shame to her family. “You are a dirty girl,” she told her daughter. “You fell in love with a dirty Sunni boy. I would kill you before I would let you marry him. I bet you are supporting him because he had sex with you at the university.”

Her aunts visited weekly and focused on insulting her mother. “Shame on this girl,” an aunt said. “She ruined our families. What would people say if they hear about her filthy love?”

At one point Samana’s cousin offered to marry her to save the family’s honor. He bargained for her as if she was a piece of cheap cloth. The family accepted but Samana, courageously, refused and somehow they did not press the issue. In the midst of this, Khalid offered to become a Shia; his love for Samana was more important to him than any religion. This, though, was rejected by Samana’s father who said “his roots are Sunni.”

One dark night, in keeping with the plans made by phone, Samana skipped out of bed, opened the yard door and sweating in fear, left her family's house. Khalid was waiting for her outside with a car. In an attempt to circumvent Afghan law that could enable them to be punished for sex outside of marriage, Khalid arranged for a religious clergyman, a mullah, to marry them. Samana wore a traditional white veil and said yes to “Nikah,” which is a religious way of bonding two people. Then the couple left Kabul and moved to Mazar Sharif.

Samana’s father saw only blood when this happened. He said he would not rest until he killed his daughter and Khalid. He and his sons searched everywhere to find Samana but they could not find her. Now they were even more ashamed because their daughter had managed to escape. Samana’s father took out his anger on his wife and beat her for raising an immodest girl. Officially, he disowned his daughter.

On The Issues Magazine - Rezaie ©Mahnaz Rezaie I have asked myself if it would have been different in my friend’s family if Samana fell in love with a Shia boy? I do not think so. The traditional families think of love as a shame and crime. They want arranged marriages. In their opinion a girl who falls in love without family’s permission, religion aside, is filthy.

In Afghanistan, men call their women “Namous,” which means “honor." The way they apply this word, however, is different from that meaning in English. “Namous” is a word that men use to control women and to justify violence. They also use another word, “Qeirat,” which means “zeal." Afghan men say their “Qeirat” does not allow them to see their women with men these women select by themselves.

Back to Hot Topics Home

Mahnaz Rezaie was born in western Afghanistan. Her family valued education for all. But they practiced the Shia form of Islam and this made them particularly vulnerable when the Taliban  took power in 1996. Rezaie was eight at the time. Fear – and poverty – forced her and her family to flee to Iran, where they faced more economic discrimination and educational discrimination as well. After the fall of the Taliban in 2001, Rezaie’s family returned  to Afghanistan. Rezaie studied diligently and was awarded a scholarship to continue her studies in the United States at Middlebury College in Vermont where she is now an undergraduate. Click here to view more writing by Mahnaz Rezaie.


Stacy Le Melle posted: 2012-12-06 12:48:20

My heart is still racing after finishing this, Mahnaz. I am deeply saddened that Samana and Khalid had to flee like this, and cut off their deepest family ties--this kind of severance is just that, a severance, a deep trauma for all. But I pray that this couple can make a new, beautiful life for themselves. Thank you for sharing this with all of us.

Elizabeth Titus posted: 2012-12-13 16:32:28

Dear Mahnaz, I live in NYC and recently met an Afghan woman, Tabasum Wolayat, who graduated from Middlebury, where you are now. She is at Oxford University and we stay in touch. Because of brave young woman like Tabasum and you, who are getting college educations against all odds, I decided to focus my volunteer efforts on Afghan women. Your essay adds to my growing knowledge of conditions in Afghanistan. Many thanks and best wishes, Liz

Join the conversation. Leave a comment.

All comments will be reviewed before being published. This is a space for thoughtful and critical commentary; any personal attacks, abusive or offensive language, off-topic comments or comments that may be harmful to the conversation or to readers will not be published. *All fields required.*


Hot Topics

Content on this page requires a newer version of Adobe Flash Player.

Get Adobe Flash player

What’s concerning us, feminists and progressives? From the front lines to the back burners, our angle on vital matters on our minds and popping up in the news.


Intimate Wars

Intimate Wars book cover
The Life and Times
of the Woman
Who Brought Abortion
from the
Back Alley
to the
Board Room

• Merle Hoffman, publisher of On The Issues Magazine

Print page      Bookmark site      Rss Feed RSS Feed

1983-2015 On The Issues Magazine; No Reuse without permission. • Complete Table of ContentsPrivacyLinks of Feminist and Progressive Interest